after_logo=999 feature does not work an logo disappearing
after_logo=999 feature does not work an logo disappearing
Hi
I have set both after_logo and before_logo to 999. Cutpoints are only set on logo appearing.
Thanks
I have set both after_logo and before_logo to 999. Cutpoints are only set on logo appearing.
Thanks
-
- Posts: 1
- Joined: Wed Feb 11, 2009 12:05 am
Re: after_logo=999 feature does not work an logo disappearing
I have noticed the same issue. With just detect_method=2 (logo) with or without the after_logo don't seem to work at 80.012. The detection seems to be working fine, its the decision to put a cut point that has gone mising. I have also noticed the "volume of -1" as mentioned elsewhere is not being used to help detect cut points
Re: after_logo=999 feature does not work an logo disappearing
This should be solved in build 0.80.013 being release as I am writing this
Re: after_logo=999 feature does not work an logo disappearing
The problem is NOT resolved for me. Still same behaviour.
Re: after_logo=999 feature does not work an logo disappearing
The before/after logo cuts do NOT happen if the distance till the next logo block is less then 1/4 of the max_commercial_break
Re: after_logo=999 feature does not work an logo disappearing
Ok I try it. But i like the other heuristics very much, why should I play with other parameters in order to only get the one thing -> cutpoints when logo disappearing.
So my suggestion. Would it be a bad idea to introduce an extra switch?
cutpoint_on_logoswitch= 1
which get the wanted behavior. The "hack" with the after_logo=999 wouldn't than be needed.
Thanks
So my suggestion. Would it be a bad idea to introduce an extra switch?
cutpoint_on_logoswitch= 1
which get the wanted behavior. The "hack" with the after_logo=999 wouldn't than be needed.
Thanks
Re: after_logo=999 feature does not work an logo disappearing
The rule to add a cutpoint when logo (dis)appears without paying attention to the sound level is a bad approach.
In general it creates more problems then it solves.
Just imagine your broadcaster has some kind of promotion and inserts a moving logo during the last couple of seconds of the show.
You will lose that part of the show.
In general it creates more problems then it solves.
Just imagine your broadcaster has some kind of promotion and inserts a moving logo during the last couple of seconds of the show.
You will lose that part of the show.
Re: after_logo=999 feature does not work an logo disappearing
Hi again
Even if the criteria max_commercial_break is fullfilled it does not work. I have sent you an zip archive.
Thanks
Even if the criteria max_commercial_break is fullfilled it does not work. I have sent you an zip archive.
Thanks
Re: after_logo=999 feature does not work an logo disappearing
Will have a look tonight
Re: after_logo=999 feature does not work an logo disappearing
Hi Erik
I do not seek for a comskip.ini that is good for all kinds of recordings
My actual application is a TV series. I record one episode each day. The way in which the logo is overladed and other things does not change from day to day. I would really like to be able to tune comskip in such a way, that I do not have to review its results, but to automate the encoding/cutting process.
In the case it would be perfect if comskip would cut whenever the logo appears or disappears. And thats why I am asking for it.
Thanks
PS. Should we move this topic to feature requests?
You are right. BUT ...erik wrote:The rule to add a cutpoint when logo (dis)appears without paying attention to the sound level is a bad approach.
In general it creates more problems then it solves.
Just imagine your broadcaster has some kind of promotion and inserts a moving logo during the last couple of seconds of the show.
You will lose that part of the show.
I do not seek for a comskip.ini that is good for all kinds of recordings
My actual application is a TV series. I record one episode each day. The way in which the logo is overladed and other things does not change from day to day. I would really like to be able to tune comskip in such a way, that I do not have to review its results, but to automate the encoding/cutting process.
In the case it would be perfect if comskip would cut whenever the logo appears or disappears. And thats why I am asking for it.
Thanks
PS. Should we move this topic to feature requests?
Re: after_logo=999 feature does not work an logo disappearing
Did you test the latest build?
Does it work?
Does it work?